XGate and Opal, compared
Opal is the screen-time app most people have tried, and it is good. Over a million people open it every day, most of them on a phone. If you are reading this page, you have probably met its limit: the rules are yours to switch off, and one night you did.
Choose Opal if
- Your phone is the problem and your Mac isn't
- You keep the rules you set, and want a score and streaks to keep you company
- You don't own a Mac
Choose XGate if
- You've removed Opal before, and would rather someone you trust held the key this time
- Your Mac is where the evening goes
- You want admin access back when you need it, not a wall
Side by side
| XGate | Opal | |
|---|---|---|
| Who holds the key | A Guardian you choose: the administrator password and recovery key of your Mac. Or XGate itself | You. Opal suggests a friend set your iOS Screen Time passcode |
| On the Mac | Every browser and every app, from a daemon; block pages in Chrome and Safari | Browser extensions; no Firefox; app limits at a later date |
| On the iPhone | Screen Time shields, the same rules as your Mac, your Guardian's PIN | Its strongest platform: sessions, Deep Focus, app uninstall protection |
| Uninstall | Not by you: you're a standard user | Yes, outside a session |
| Admin when you need it | Ask, say why, wait a few minutes, get a temporary admin account for the time you asked | n/a |
| Relaxing a rule | Takes effect in 6 hours; your Guardian can approve sooner or deny | Timeout mode: the wait grows each time; Deep Focus: no exit |
| Someone else involved | A Guardian with requests, a weekly letter and alerts; they pay nothing | Friends and leaderboards for motivation; no approvals |
| What they see | Counts, set names, your reasons. Never pages or screenshots | Your Opal Score and streaks |
| Price | Free for one Mac; Plus $49 a year or $4.99 a month | Free with limits; Pro $99.99 a year, $19.99 a month |
Checked 28 October 2026 from opal.so, Opal's help centre and the US App Store listing.
Where Opal is better
The iPhone. Opal's sessions, its score and its uninstall protection are polished, the free tier is real, and Opal for Schools is a product in its own right. If you don't own a Mac, Opal is the better choice and we would say so.
Where XGate is better
The Mac, and the morning after. On a Mac, Opal is a browser extension; XGate is a daemon that closes a site in every browser and quits a closed app within a second. And the thing Opal's own forum has been asking for all year, a peer key, an accountability partner, a friend who can approve, is what XGate is. A Guardian who holds the keys, receives each request with your reason, can approve it sooner or deny it, sees counts and never content, and pays nothing.
Opal asks you to keep your own rules. XGate asks someone you trust to keep them with you.
How XGate holds
A standard account. Nothing on the Mac to find, nothing you can remove on impulse.
Holds the administrator password and the recovery key. Sees that a set opened, never what was behind it.
Say why, wait a few minutes, work as an administrator for the time you asked. Logged, then removed.
You keep a standard account. A Guardian you choose holds the only administrator password and the recovery key, and sees them once, on their own page. Sites, apps and whole categories go into sets, each with its hours and its opens a day. A stricter rule applies the moment you set it. A relaxed one takes effect in 6 hours, and your Guardian can approve it sooner or deny it. When you need administrator access, you ask from the menu bar, say why, and a temporary administrator account appears for the time you asked, logged and then removed. If you would rather not ask anyone, XGate can be your Guardian: it holds the keys, every relaxed rule takes effect after a day, and a contact you name can say no.
Questions
Can I use both?
Yes. XGate on the Mac and Opal on the phone, or XGate on both with Opal's sessions on top. They don't interfere.
Does XGate have a score or streaks?
No. It sends one weekly letter with real numbers: hours open this week against last, and a line per set. We left the gems out on purpose.
Is XGate on the App Store?
The iPhone app is on TestFlight while XGate is in beta: join here. The Mac app is a download from this site, because an app that holds your administrator password can't be sandboxed.
Sources
- opal.so, pricing and How can I make Opal foolproof, October 2026.
- community.opal.so: Peer Key Unlock System, Accountability Partner, Provide an accountability partner, 2026.
- RevenueCat, Sub Club, April 2026 (daily users and the freemium figures).
- App Store US listing for Opal: Screen Time Control.
Checked 28 October 2026. If we have something wrong, email support@itch.studio and we'll correct it.
Also compared: Cold Turkey, Freedom, Jomo, Covenant Eyes, Qustodio, Apple Screen Time, or all of them side by side.
Hand over the keys
Free for one Mac, macOS 14 or later. The iPhone app is on TestFlight while XGate is in beta, and a Guardian pays nothing.