XGate and Freedom, compared
Freedom is the blocker that follows you: one dashboard, the same session on your Mac, your phone and your tablet, and a Locked Mode that stops you ending it early. Most reviews call it the best all-rounder. The lock, though, is yours, and so is the uninstaller.
Choose Freedom if
- You move between four devices a day and want one session on all of them
- You like focus sounds and a session history
- You keep the rules you set
Choose XGate if
- You want the Mac held by someone else, with the same rules on your iPhone
- You want admin back by asking, not an escape once a week
- You'd rather nobody, including you, could uninstall it on a whim
Side by side
| XGate | Freedom | |
|---|---|---|
| Who holds the key | A Guardian you choose, or XGate itself | You |
| On the Mac | Every browser and app, from a daemon | Websites and apps |
| On the iPhone | Screen Time, the same rules as your Mac | A VPN profile; reviewers note the battery |
| Uninstall | Not by you | Yes; Freedom says so |
| Relaxing a rule | Takes effect in 6 hours; the Guardian can approve sooner or deny | Locked Mode holds until the session ends; one End Session a week from the dashboard |
| Scheduled sessions | Hours per set, by the half hour, every day | Yes; reviewers report sessions missed when the app hasn't been opened |
| Someone else involved | A Guardian with requests, alerts and a weekly letter | Nobody |
| Price | Free for one Mac; Plus $49 a year | $8.99 a month, $39.99 a year, Forever $99.50 to $199 by storefront |
Checked 28 October 2026 from freedom.to and reviews at makeheadway.com, makerstack.co and toolradar.com.
Where Freedom is better
Breadth. Windows, Mac, iPhone, iPad, Android and Chromebook from one dashboard, with focus sounds and a history of every session. If you work across many devices in a day, Freedom's sync is the whole point, and nothing else does it as well.
Where XGate is better
Depth on the Mac. Freedom can be uninstalled and gives you a weekly escape; XGate takes administrator away and gives it back on request, so there is no escape to find and nothing to feel bad about using. Your rules reach your iPhone through Screen Time, which keeps working when the app is closed. And your Guardian sees that a set opened, never what you did.
Freedom's Locked Mode is a door you lock from the inside. XGate's Guardian is a door locked from the outside, by someone who wants you to sleep.
How XGate holds
A standard account. Nothing on the Mac to find, nothing you can remove on impulse.
Holds the administrator password and the recovery key. Sees that a set opened, never what was behind it.
Say why, wait a few minutes, work as an administrator for the time you asked. Logged, then removed.
You keep a standard account. A Guardian you choose holds the only administrator password and the recovery key, and sees them once, on their own page. Sites, apps and whole categories go into sets, each with its hours and its opens a day. A stricter rule applies the moment you set it. A relaxed one takes effect in 6 hours, and your Guardian can approve it sooner or deny it. When you need administrator access, you ask from the menu bar, say why, and a temporary administrator account appears for the time you asked, logged and then removed. If you would rather not ask anyone, XGate can be your Guardian: it holds the keys, every relaxed rule takes effect after a day, and a contact you name can say no.
Questions
Does XGate have Freedom's focus sounds?
No. XGate blocks; it doesn't play anything.
Can I run a session on four devices at once?
Up to 5 devices on Plus, Macs and iPhones, with one set of rules. Android and Windows later.
Is there a lifetime price?
Not yet; planned after the beta.
Sources
- freedom.to, pricing, October 2026.
- makeheadway.com, Freedom App Review; makerstack.co, Freedom Review (2026).
- toolradar.com, Freedom pricing, 2026.
Checked 28 October 2026. If we have something wrong, email support@itch.studio and we'll correct it.
Also compared: Opal, Cold Turkey, Jomo, Covenant Eyes, Qustodio, Apple Screen Time, or all of them side by side.
Hand over the keys
Free for one Mac, macOS 14 or later. The iPhone app is on TestFlight while XGate is in beta, and a Guardian pays nothing.