XGate and Covenant Eyes, compared
Covenant Eyes is the largest accountability product, built for people quitting porn, mostly within a faith. An ally receives reports and, on the Mac, blurred screen captures. For many people that works. If what you want is the other person's help without the other person's eyes, XGate is the other way of doing it.
Choose Covenant Eyes if
- You want a partner who sees what you looked at, and a community built around that conversation
- Your church or group already uses it
- The report, and talking about it, is what helps you
Choose XGate if
- You want the sites closed and nobody watching
- You want the other person to hold the key, not the view
- You'd never install anything that takes a screenshot
Side by side
| XGate | Covenant Eyes | |
|---|---|---|
| Who holds the key | A Guardian you choose, or XGate itself | Nobody; an uninstall code and tamper alerts |
| What the other person sees | That a set opened or was blocked, your reason, admin requests. Never a page, screenshot or keyword | Screen captures, blurred and rated, with reports; on the Mac through Victory Shield |
| Blocking | Sets of sites, apps and categories closed except in the hours you set; the adult list always closed | Optional; the product is the report |
| On the Mac | Every browser and app, from a daemon; you're a standard user | Screen capture and analysis |
| Uninstall | Not by you | With a code the ally holds |
| Relaxing a rule | Takes effect in 6 hours; the Guardian can approve sooner or deny | Change it; the ally is told after |
| Who it's for | Any adult with any pattern: social, streaming, games, news, gambling, adult sites | Mainly porn; a faith-based community |
| Price | Free for one Mac; Plus $49 a year | About $16.99 a month; family plans |
Checked 28 October 2026 from covenanteyes.com and third-party comparisons at canopy.us and airdroid.com.
Where Covenant Eyes is better
The community and the conversation. Covenant Eyes has years of material, groups, and a model that many churches run on. If the report and the talk about it are what help you, it was built for exactly that.
Where XGate is better
Privacy and the key. XGate never takes a screenshot; the privacy policy and the role page both say so. Your Guardian sees that a door opened, never what was behind it, and they hold the keys so the door stays shut when you want it shut. The adult list is always closed, so there is nothing to report. It is secular, and it works as well for the news at midnight as for anything else.
An ally watches the room. A Guardian holds the door.
How XGate holds
A standard account. Nothing on the Mac to find, nothing you can remove on impulse.
Holds the administrator password and the recovery key. Sees that a set opened, never what was behind it.
Say why, wait a few minutes, work as an administrator for the time you asked. Logged, then removed.
You keep a standard account. A Guardian you choose holds the only administrator password and the recovery key, and sees them once, on their own page. Sites, apps and whole categories go into sets, each with its hours and its opens a day. A stricter rule applies the moment you set it. A relaxed one takes effect in 6 hours, and your Guardian can approve it sooner or deny it. When you need administrator access, you ask from the menu bar, say why, and a temporary administrator account appears for the time you asked, logged and then removed. If you would rather not ask anyone, XGate can be your Guardian: it holds the keys, every relaxed rule takes effect after a day, and a contact you name can say no.
Questions
Does XGate block adult sites?
Yes, always, on the Mac and the iPhone, with safe search on. The guide.
Can my therapist or sponsor be my Guardian?
Yes. Anyone with an email address. They see counts and your reasons, which is often exactly what the conversation needs.
Is XGate religious?
No.
Sources
- covenanteyes.com, pricing and Victory Shield, October 2026.
- canopy.us, Canopy vs Covenant Eyes; airdroid.com, Canopy vs Covenant Eyes, 2026.
- getzenview.com, 6 Best Porn Blockers for Mac in 2026.
Checked 28 October 2026. If we have something wrong, email support@itch.studio and we'll correct it.
Also compared: Opal, Cold Turkey, Freedom, Jomo, Qustodio, Apple Screen Time, or all of them side by side.
Hand over the keys
Free for one Mac, macOS 14 or later. The iPhone app is on TestFlight while XGate is in beta, and a Guardian pays nothing.